Amish midwife Anne Stoltzfus is used to late-night visitors, but she's shocked to find reclusive bachelor Joseph Lapp on her doorstep with a baby in his arms. Their neighborly quarrels aside, Joseph explains that his sister left her daughter in his care, and he needs Anne to be her nanny. Soon they're bonding over baby Leah, and their love for her is healing them both. But when Joseph makes an offer of marriage, Anne's painful past resurfaces and she's unsure of what to do. Could love and family be waiting just across the fence?